Core answer: pick Cai (Fox Obelisk) first for the smoothest opening. The first path is the longest and teaches the game; later paths get faster because Boons, map unlocks, and some quest progress carry over after you finish a route.

Decide in This Order

1. Cai (Fox Obelisk)Smoothest first 20 hours

Balanced opening party (Cai mounted, Tialla support magic, Peter archer, Ultand attack magic), faster Renown from side work, plus beast taming and farm plots. Use taming and farming when they appear - that is his path identity and it pays in mounts and money.

2. Theodora (Wolf)Politics, Part 2 center

The most traditional Fire Emblem story and the one that hits hardest. Battalions and gambits are her unique kit. Part 2 (War) is essentially her war even if you bring another lord. Some starters here wished they had Cai's Renown and Boons first.

3. Dietrich (Lion)Combat + lore, harder open

Strongest personal combat, combat-art farming by killing, Answerer world-map fights, richest recruiting, every Paralogue visible. Also the path players warn about opening on if you hate a steep first combat curve. Save him for when the game has clicked.

4. Leda (Eagle)Support lord, personal story

Dancer/troupe path with tavern performances for intel and drinks (stat tonics). Best starting team according to players who cleared all four, weaker personal trigger on her own arts. Least main-plot, most character-focused.

Common full-route orders: Cai → Theodora → Dietrich → Leda, or Theodora → Cai → Leda → Dietrich. Either beats starting Dietrich or hopping four routes one chapter at a time.

1What to Do in the First Session (Any Lord)

Decision Points

You care most aboutFirst pathWhy
Learning the game, Renown, mountsCaiEasiest ramp, fastest recruit economy
Story and Part 2 contextTheodoraPolitics, battalions, she is the War arc center
Combat and Fodlan leftoversDietrichArts, Answerer, lore - harder open
Support play, revenge hook, rosterLedaTroupe, drinks, personal plot
Seeing everything once, efficientlyFinish one Part 1, then the other three, then one Part 2 and skip the rest
You only need one completed Part 1 to unlock Part 2. You need each lord's War clear (or the skip after the first War) if you want that lord's army in Part 3.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

You can replay the prologue later to change difficulty, Classic/Casual, or Eshmel's look without wiping path progress. Two prologue fights again is the only cost.

Video Breakdown

Lucky Crit - path identities and who each one is for; still the clip players link when this question comes up